This is our family’s favorite eggnog, and it has graced our holiday table for many years. Be sure to let the egg yolks mingle with the liquor in your refrigerator for the full time. If you don’t, your nog may taste more like a naughty omelet than holiday cheer. This eggnog will keep indefinitely in the refrigerator (in fact, some would argue that eggnog improves with time; we can at least vouch for it still being wonderfully tasty for up to a year). If desired, reserve the egg whites, beat them to stiff peaks with a couple tablespoons sugar, and fold them into the eggnog just before serving. See About Egg Safety.
Beat in a large bowl until light in color:
Gradually beat in:
Add very slowly, beating constantly:
Let stand, covered, in the refrigerator for 1 hour to dispel the eggy taste.
Add, beating constantly:
Refrigerate, covered, for at least 3 hours. Serve sprinkled with: